| Margaret McLaren | 1974 | Sandra Livingston | 1975 |
| Audrey Schell | 1976 | Wendy Harrington | 1977 |
| Kimberly Hoskin | 1978 | Barbara Schell | 1979 |
| Harle Barclay | 1980 | Karen Etherington | 1981 |
| Donna Duncan | 1982 | Wendy Kipp | 1983 |
| Cretia Willaimson | 1984 | Karen Banko | 1985 |
| Suzy Perry | 1986 | Susan Yeck | 1987 |
| Lisa Meacham | 1988 | Cathy McLaggan | 1989 |
| Lorraine Kesteloot | 1990 | Kelly Leuszler | 1991 |
| Julie Symons | 1992 | Ellen Johnson | 1993 |
| Julie Harrison | 1996 | Kristen Michiels | 1997 |
| Shawna Tregunna | 1998 | Jessica Stephenson | 1999 |
| Heather McLaren | 2000 | Sarah Harrington | 2001 |
| Ashley Mitchell | 2002 | Brittany Becker | 2003 |
| Valerie Blake | 2004 | Breanne Becker | 2005 |
| Nichele Palen | 2006 | Sinead Miller | 2007 |
| Danielle DeGrace | 2008 | Jaclyn Pynenburg | 2009 |
| Virginia Dibble | 2010 | Evelyn Sparling | 2011 |
| Reta McLean | 2012 | Susannah Sparling | 2013 |
| Rachel McLean | 2014 |
